Welcome to the Pantry
Subscribe and Save
Making regular purchases? Join the society today and save 10% on all future orders. Plus you will receive regular recipes to your inbox and priority release to new products and events.
Orders are processed in 48hours (Wednesday - Saturday). You will receive a confirmation email with a delivery date and time. Please note we are closed Monday + Tuesday so any orders made on these days will be processed when we open again on Wednesday.
Sourdough Starter x Meet “Arthur”- The What If Society’s three-year-old sourdough starter, who made a trip down from Nelsons Bay from a dear friend by the name of David Moon. x Dive into the fascinating world of fermentation and learn to make your own bread with your very own starter from our Arthur. X Keep your eye out for Mr Moon in all sorts of What if Society events and classes; he’s a talent in the kitchen, a master of the ovens and a sincere friend of founder Eilish Maloney.
Choose from freshly baked cookies or buy yourself some of our cookie dough to bake at home! Cookie dough - makes six - $20.00 x Invite your kids into the kitchen and together, bake up some delicious cookies with our pre-made cookie dough. Easy to cook, and even easier to eat! Cookies - $4.00 per cookie or five cookies for $16.00 x Chocolate, Oat + Sea Salt
Auntie Rach’s Brownies - 6 for $28, 12 for $55 or 24 for $106 x A decadent brownie made from the finest Australian ingredients - and solely mixed by hand in house by our team. x Lovely rich flavour and the perfect sweet treat to share with friends over a cup of tea
Tin Loaf Apple and Cinnamon Tin Loaf ( If a blind tasting you’d mistake it for banana bread Expect for the apple and cinnamon flavour) x Suits this time of year with a hint of nutmeg and cardamon to bring in that Christmas cheer. x Like a muffin but in a loaf form. x Lite, fluffy and easy to freeze for ease of convenience at a later date. Accompany with butter, greek yoghurt or enjoy by itself. Crowd pleaser
Sourdough Loaf of Unbleached White Sourdough - $10.00 Loaf of Whole Wheat Sourdough - $9.00 x Our selection of sourdough breads are certified organic and always made using sustainable, stone-milled eastern-Australian flour and make them by hand. x All our breads are wrapped in a recycled - and recyclable - brown paper bag.
Seven flavours to choose from: x Carrot Cake. Whipped Vanilla Labneh Buttercream. x Upside Down Pickled Berry. Little Big Dairy Cream. x Lemon Zest. Lemon Vanilla Buttercream. Drizzled with Zingy Lemon Curd. x Family Size Tiramisu. x Lavender. Lemon. Olive Oil. x Pumpkin Honey and Yoghurt. x Lemon Tart.